About a third of the questions that appear in the GMAT verbal section are critical reasoning questions. Typical questions that appear in critical reasoning include strengthening an argument, weakening an argument, identifying the assumption of an argument, and evaluating an argument.
If you have difficulty in solving these questions, go to the explanatory answer or the video explanations (wherever provided) to learn how to crack the question.
Linda: In the 1800s, it was found that one in every six women who gave birth in hospitals died of a fever they had contracted after delivering the child and that the mortality was not as high if they gave birth at home with the help of a mid wife. It was found that the doctors had a poorer sense of hygiene and that their dirty hands and instruments were leading to pathogens entering a woman's bloodstream. Thankfully, hygienic conditions today are much better and women are safer.
Which of the following can be used by Fiona to further establish that Linda need not be correct in her reasoning?
- A nationwide survey found that doctors, especially experienced ones, are more prone to the belief that they could not possibly be carrying pathogens.
- It is reported that around 50,000 people die every year in our country from hospital acquired infections.
- Compulsory hand cleansing is strictly adhered to by all doctors and nurses before every major surgical procedure.
- During a study, doctors handling newborn babies self reported a hand cleansing rate of 90℅.
- Nurses are not any better than doctors in adhering to strict cleansing schedules, especially when busy.
Which of the following best explains this seeming discrepancy?
- A number of differently-abled people chose not to work
- Not willing to deal with the issues of workplace discrimination of the differently-abled, several companies recruited fewer of them in the first place
- Knowing that the act was about to be enforced, companies terminated some of the differently-abled while they had a chance
- There was no act introduced that would guarantee a job for the differently-abled
- The unemployment among the able-bodied has remained consistently hig
Which of the following is the most relevant information in evaluating the credibility of the argument?
- Whether efforts have been successfully taken in any other country to regulate drug users.
- Whether the payoff from selling drugs outweighs the severity of the punishment
- Whether drugs will continue to be sold at a premium when there are dealers in the market again
- Whether the majority of the users will be willing to pay a premium to continue to use the drugs
- Whether the government will be able to keep track of new dealers as and when they enter the market
Alan: In the last 15 years, most of the criminals who were convicted of theft or murder were from the lower income classes and had not completed high school. Therefore, the government has to spend more money on reducing poverty and increase funding to education. Because terrorism is the most severe of all crimes, such measures would bring down overall crime rate and reduce threat from terrorism.
Which of the following best describes Dylan's response to Alan?
- Dylan changes the direction of the argument entirely by discussing the scenario in a different country
- Dylan partially agrees with Alan's reasoning but refutes his recommendation to the government
- Dylan converts a causal argument made by Alan into a generalization applicable universally
- Dylan challenges Alan's reasoning by explaining why two situations that Alan perceives as similar are not
- While Alan arrives at a conclusion by drawing an analogy, Dylan arrives at the same conclusion by refuting the analogy
Which of the following best explains why the conclusion need not be the best explanation for the statistic?
- Of the remaining members, 60℅ or more tend to be born between the months of April and June.
- Parents of kids born in the second half of the year have displayed a measurable intent to promote scholarly careers
- The age cut-off for kids to try out for a team in most European countries is calculated as on December 31 of any year and older the kid during trials, greater the chances of getting the right opportunities.
- The school year usually begins in April in most European countries and many parents are known to encourage students to work on their academics and not sports during the school year.
- During the last 50 years, on average 30℅ of the kids have been born during the first three months of the year.
What is the role of the sentences in boldface?
- The first establishes a theory that the author later clearly refutes while the second presents the author's conclusion
- The first is an interpretation made by researchers that the author contends against and the second provides an alternative explanation for statistical data
- The first is an opinion expressed by someone other than the author and which the author is completely in disagreement with while the second provides the reason for the author's doubt
- The first is a fact supporting the researcher's conclusion while the second is the author's conclusion.
- The first is a clearly proven opinion even if the author disagrees with it while the second is an ambiguous opinion that has no supporting data
Which of the following best refutes the author's reasoning?
- In countries with a royal family, the eldest son of the king is destined to be the next king.
- The blacksmith's eldest son in a mediaeval village could not choose any other profession even if he wanted to.
- A major baseball player will have better knowledge and skills and will be able to guide his son better.
- 60℅ of the country's doctors have at least one parent who is a doctor.
- It is a proven fact that success in any career is determined more by skill and practice rather than by genetic makeup.
Which of the following best explains the apparent paradox?
- The city does not pay welfare unless the applicants have at least some things working for them
- Claiming that they do not have a car or a TV ensures that the city looks at the applicant more favorably
- While the applicants may be willing to accept that they don't have certain things, they felt embarrassed having to accept that they don't have most things.
- Historically, at least 30℅ of the claims have had people understating what they have while only 22℅ overstated what they had.
- The people who understated what they had were not the same people who overstated what they had
Which of the following options gives one more option as to why the crime rate decreased because of the terrorist attacks?
- The capital city is under increased monitoring leading to quick detection of crimes - many times while the crime is still underway.
- A number of people are frightened because of the terrorist attacks and have fled the capital city.
- There was a recorded decrease in crime rate right after the terrorist attack in almost all cities of the country.
- Intel reports show that the terrorists who pulled off the attack had been committing various other smaller crimes regularly to distract law enforcement from their true purposes.
- The government had initiated schemes to decrease poverty and provide better livelihood for the people just before the terrorist attack.
Which of the following can then explain the discrepancy?
- The government announced in 2008 that estate taxes, payable by the heirs on someone's death, would be abolished effective from the new year.
- Astrologists predicted that 2009 was a good year to die in, for salvation of the soul.
- The statistic is an anomaly that has no logical explanation.
- The price of some cancer drugs and chemotherapy increased by 10% in January 2009, making treatment more expensive than before.
- An earthquake in one of the cities during December 2008 made hospital care availability more difficult for regular illnesses.
All of the following underscore the author’s argument EXCEPT
- Most hospitals require doctors to do so much paperwork that they spend insufficient time on direct patient care.
- Most hospitals recirculate air and therefore, it is very easy for diseases such as anthrax to spread through the hospital.
- In smaller cities, the ambulance service is on a voluntary basis and the response time for calls is much lower than the national average, leading to a higher loss of life.
- A number of doctors in private hospitals are not held accountable by the administration for the loss of patients.
- Doctors in most private hospitals have performance appraisals based on how much money they have brought in for the hospital rather than based on how effectively they treated patients.
Which of the following best describes the author's reasoning?
- The author establishes a point by drawing an analogy
- The author disproves a popular notion by providing evidence that is contrary to it
- The author presents a new theory in response to an existing well-established theory
- The author uses an illustration to support a new school of thought that is contrary to a popular school of thought
- The author makes a comparison between two theories by providing an example
Which of the following best further corroborate the author’s argument?
- A study result that shows that the effect of automobile pollution on global warming is marginal.
- An unverified study gaining popularity because it seemingly showed that red wine reduces the risk of cancer on a very small control group.
- A new study that further collaborates an earlier finding that the consumption of some types of berries lower the risk of heart failure.
- The news media highlighting the fact that a study had clearly proven that effects of certain drugs on rats need not be the same as on humans.
- People not knowing what to believe because one study shows that a certain disease is caused by genetic factors, while another shows that it also caused by lifestyle factors.
John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.
Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?
- If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.
- Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.
- It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSD
- Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.
- There have been instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.
Jess: To be a woman in this century is far better than to be a woman in centuries past. Life expectancy for women has - for the first time - surpassed that for men and while only around 20℅ of college students in the late 1800s were women, today, almost 60℅ of college students are women.
Which of the following is Jess most likely to say in response to Sam?
- Women today are healthier and live longer than women in the 1800s, who primarily died because of child birth.
- There are more women at the entry-level jobs of most industries than there are men.
- Women today are better able to juggle professional and personal lives and a number of them are proving to be successful single mothers.
- The proportion of women in the judicial and legislative branches of the country is at its highest and the country elected its first woman president recently.
- Women are allowed more freedom today and are not likely to be sacrificed at the altar of marriage or in a witch hunt.